Intelligence Oversight and Effectiveness in New Democracies

The Case of Brazil

  • Clara Ribeiro Assumpção University of Glasgow, Dublin City University and Charles University in Prague
Keywords: Brazil, Democratic Transition, Government, Intelligence Oversight, Intelligence Studies, Latin America

Abstract

Scholarship on the inherent tension between intelligence and democracy has paid limited attention to new democracies, especially those transitioning from military regimes. There, it is more challenging to bring intelligence services under democratic control without sacrificing their efficiency in exchange for oversight. This research note analyses these challenges in the Brazilian case, contributing to the scholarship on intelligence in Latin America. The case study demonstrates that the restructuring of intelligence in Brazil resulted in a spread-out intelligence system with many agencies, aimed at avoiding monopolisation and politicisation with formal oversight mechanisms put in place. Nonetheless, Brazilian society and politicians still do not trust intelligence, and lack a clear understanding of its functions for a democratic state. While intelligence reform in Brazil still has a long way to go regarding intelligence effectiveness and efficiency, it indicates how intelligence reform is a central part of a successful democratic transition.

Author Biography

Clara Ribeiro Assumpção, University of Glasgow, Dublin City University and Charles University in Prague

Clara Ribeiro Assumpção, from Juiz de Fora (Brazil), is a graduate student who received her Bachelor’s degree in “International Relations” at the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro in 2017. In 2018, she joined the MA in International Security, Strategy and Intelligence Studies taught jointly by the University of Glasgow, Dublin City University and Charles University in Prague. She is currently writing her Master’s Thesis on the (In)Security Implications of Russia’s Security Doctrine. Her interests include regional security studies, gender and security studies, critical terrorism studies, post-soviet studies, disinformation and hybrid warfare, and the relationship between intelligence and democracies.

References

Andregg, Michael M., and Peter Gill. 2014. “Comparing the Democratization of Intelligence.” Intelligence and National Security 29 no. 4: 487–97. https://doi.org/10.1080/02684527.2014.915174
Brand, Rachel. 2016. “What Does Effective Intelligence Oversight Look Like?” Lawfare (blog). May 3, 2016. https://www.lawfareblog.com/what-does-effective-intelligence-oversight-look
Bruneau, Thomas C. 2015. “Intelligence Reform in Brazil: A Long, Drawn-Out Process.” International Journal of Intelligence and CounterIntelligence 28 no. 3: 502–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/08850607.2015.1022469
Bruneau, Thomas C., and Steven C. Boraz. 2007. “Intelligence Reform: Balancing Democracy and Effectiveness.” In Reforming Intelligence: Obstacles to Democratic Control and Effectiveness, edited by Thomas C. Bruneau and Steven C. Boraz, 1–26. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bruneau, Thomas C., and Kenneth R. Dombroski. 2006. “Reforming Intelligence: The Challenge of Control in New Democracies.” In Who Guards the Guardians and How, edited by Thomas C. Bruneau and Scott D. Tollefson, 1-27. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bruneau, Thomas C., and Florina C. Matei. 2010. “Intelligence in the Developing Democracies: The Quest for Transparency and Effectiveness.” In The Oxford Handbook of National Security Intelligence, edited by Loch K. Johnson, 756–73. New York: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780195375886.003.0045.
Carpentieri, José Rafael. 2016. “A Agência Brasileira de Inteligência e a Constituinte - O Problema da Democratização das Força Coercitivas no Brasil.” Revista Direito Mackenzie 10 no. 1: 139–63.
Cepik, Marco. 2007. “Structural Change and Democratic Control of Intelligence in Brazil”. In Reforming Intelligence, Obstacles to Democratic Control and Effectiveness, edited by Thomas C. Bruneau and Steven C. Boraz, 149-169. Austin: University of Texas Press.
———. 2018a. “Inteligência: Conceitos, política e estratégia.” Clipping Abin. Accessed May 10, 2019. https://clippingcacd.com.br/uploads/texto-cepik-semana-1-2.0.pdf.
———. 2018b. “Inteligência: Controle Externo e Organização.” January 22, 2018. http://professor.ufrgs.br/marcocepik/files/cepik_2018_texto_2_inteligencia_jan_22.pdf
Cepik, Marco, and Christiano Ambros. 2014. “Intelligence, Crisis, and Democracy: Institutional Punctuations in Brazil, Colombia, South Africa, and India.” Intelligence and National Security 29 no. 4: 523–51. https://doi.org/10.1080/02684527.2014.915176.
Datafolha. 2019. “Grau de Confiança Nas Instituições”. São Paulo: Datafolha. Instituto de Pesquisas. http://media.folha.uol.com.br/datafolha/2019/04/15/e4dfasfas453434vfa423vavsxfd429b35922gci.pdf.
During, Nelson. 2017. “Grampos Demais, Inteligência de Menos: O Desmonte da Espionagem no Brasil”. Inteligência 77 no. 2: 20-45, April 2017.
Figueiredo, Lucas. 2019. “Bolsonaro Colocou o Guarda-Costas No Comando Da Abin Para Se Proteger Dos Espiões Do Governo.” The Intercept (blog). May 28, 2019. https://theintercept.com/2019/05/27/bolsonaro-abin-guarda-costas.
Freedom House. 2018. “Freedom in the World 2018 – Brazil Profile”. https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/2018/brazil.
Gill, Peter. 1994. Policing Politics: Security Intelligence and the Liberal Democratic State. East Sussex: Psychology Press.
Gill, Peter, and Mark Phythian. 2006. Intelligence in an Insecure World, Cambridge: Polity Press.
Gonçalves, Joanisval B. 2014. “The Spies Who Came from the Tropics: Intelligence Services and Democracy in Brazil.” Intelligence and National Security 29, no. 4: 581–99. https://doi.org/10.1080/02684527.2014.915178.

Jervis, Robert. 2006. “Foreword”. In Reforming Intelligence, Obstacles to Democratic Control and Effectiveness, edited by Thomas C. Bruneau and Steven C. Boraz, viii-xx. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Linz, Juan J., and Alfred Stepan. 1996. “Democracy and Its Arenas”. In Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation: Southern Europe, South America, and Post-Communist Europe, by Linz, Juan. J, Alfred Stepan, et al., 3-15. Baltimore and London: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Matei, Florina C., and Carolyn Halladay. 2019. “The Role and Purpose of Intelligence in a Democracy”. In The Conduct of Intelligence in Democracies - Processes, Practices, Cultures, edited by Florina C. Matei and Carolyn Halladay, 1–26. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers. https://doi.org/10.1080/08850607.2020.1753462.
Mazui, Guilherme. 2019. “Ministro do GSI, general Heleno diz que sistema de inteligência foi “derretido” por Dilma”. G1. Last Modified January 2, 2019. https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2019/01/02/general-heleno-diz-que-sistema-de-inteligencia-foi-derretido-por-dilma-rousseff.ghtml.
Ministry of Defence. 2012. Política Nacional de Defesa, by Ministério da Defesa do Brasil. Brasília: Government Printing Office. Retrieved from https://www.defesa.gov.br/arquivos/estado_e_defesa/END-PND_Optimized.pdf.
Phythian, Mark. 2013. “Introduction: Beyond the Intelligence Cycle?” In Understanding the Intelligence Cycle, edited by Mark Phythian, 1-8. New York: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203558478.
Pili, Giangiuseppe, 2019. “Intelligence as an Institution of Democracy - A Philosophical Foundation of Security for Intelligence as a State Institution.” Manuscript submitted for publication, 1-14.
Rinaldi, Camila. 2019. “Bolsonaro decide, finalmente, usar celulares criptografados da Abin.” Olhar Digital, Last Modified June 13, 2019. https://olhardigital.com.br/noticia/bolsonaro-decide-finalmente-usar-celulares-criptografados-da-abin/86836.
Schedler, Andreas. 2001. “Taking Uncertainty Seriously: The Blurred Boundaries of Democratic Transition and Consolidation.” Democratization 8, no. 4: 1–22. https://doi.org/10.1080/714000225.
Shiraz, Zakia. 2014. “Intelligence and Security in the Global South: The Case of Latin America”. Presented at the FLACSO-ISA Joint International Conference, June 23-25, 2014, Buenos Aires.
TV Senado. 2017. “CCAI - Instalação - 03/04/2017.” Youtube Video, 7:25, April 3, 2017. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZM2Gg_9Ki3c.
Wills, Aidan. 2007. Guidebook: Understanding Intelligence Oversight. Geneva: Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces.
Published
2020-06-29
How to Cite
Ribeiro Assumpção, C. (2020). Intelligence Oversight and Effectiveness in New Democracies: The Case of Brazil. Politikon: The IAPSS Journal of Political Science, 45, 75-89. https://doi.org/10.22151/politikon.45.4
Section
Research notes