Populist Government and Constitutional Democracy: Radical Incompatibility or Possible Coexistence?

Francesco Maria Scanni

doi:10.22151/politikon.51.4

Authors

Francesco Maria Scanni University of Calabria

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.22151/politikon.51.4

Keywords:

Populism, Government, Democracy, Liberalism, Representation

Abstract

Until the first decade of the 21th century, scholars and reporters have identified contemporary populism as an element of anti-systemic revolt; furthermore, they have also recognized an incompatibility between populist phenomenon and government function. However, some recent cases of populist parties in power seem to be able to put into crisis more than one certainty regarding the nature and scope of the populist phenomenon. This observation raises the questions of this work: what harmful effects does populism in government produce on liberal institutions, pluralism, and representation in constitutional democracies? Do these effects merely erode the liberal component, or do they extend to produce a degeneration of democracy as a whole? And finally: what are the risks for democracy? The article corroborates the diarchic theories of democracy and aims to demonstrate the lack of compatibility between the principles of liberal democracy and populist principles, which have a negative impact not only on the liberal component, but also on the quality of democracy in its entirety.

Author Biography

Francesco Maria Scanni, University of Calabria

Francesco Maria Scanni is Ph.D in Politics, Culture and Development at the Department of Political and Social Sciences of the University of Calabria. He is the author of the monograph "Differenziazione territoriale e qualità della democrazia" Aracne, and his contributions have appeared in several international journals. His research interests lie in the field of political science and political theory. In particular, he works on populism, quality of democracy, political parties and voter analysis. Email: Francesco.scanni@unical.it.

References

Achen, Cristopher and Bartels, Larry M. 2017. Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government (Vol. 4). Princeton University Press.

Akkerman, Tjitske, de Lange, Sarah L. and Rooduijn, Matthijs, eds. 2016. Radical Right-Wing Populist Parties in Western Europe: Into the Mainstream? Routledge.

Ardeni, Pier Giorgio. 2020. Le Radici del Populismo, Roma-Bari, Laterza.

Arditi, Benjamin. 2004. Populism As a Spectre of Democracy: a Response to Canovan, in “Political Studies”, 52(1), pp. 135-143.

Aslanidis, Paris. 2017. Avoiding Bias in the Study of Populism, in “Chinese Political Science Review”, 2(3), pp. 266-287.

Baldini, Gianluca. 2014. Populismo e Democrazia Rappresentativa in Europa, in “Quaderni di Sociologia”, (65), pp. 11-29.

Beck, Ulrich. 2005. Power in the Global Age: A New Global Political Economy, Polity Press.

Bendix, Reinhard. 1964. National-building and CItizenship, Verlag nicht ermittelbar.

Berman, Sheri. 2008. Taming Extremist Parties: Lessons from Europe, in “Journal of Democracy”, 19(1), pp. 5-18.

Blokker, Paul. 2013. New Democracies in Crisis?: A Comparative Constitutional Study of the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Slovakia, Routledge.

Blokker, Paul. 2018. Il Costituzionalismo Populista, in Anselmi, M., Blokker, P. and Urbinati, N. 2018. Populismo di Lotta e di Governo, Milano, Fondazione Giacomo Feltrinelli.

Blokker, Paul. 2018. Populist Constitutionalism, in “Routledge Handbook of Global Populism”, pp. 113-127.

Canovan, Margaret. 1999. Trust the People! Populism and the Two Faces of Democracy, in “Political Studies”, vol. 47, issue 1, pp. 2-16

Corrias, Luigi. 2016. Populism in a Constitutional Key: Constituent Power, Popular Sovereignty and Constitutional Identity, in “EuConst”, 12, 6.

Dahl, Robert. A. 1956. A Preface to Democratic Theory (Vol. 115), University of Chicago Press.

Diamanti, Ilvo and Lazar, Marc. 2018. Popolocrazia. La Metamorfosi delle Nostre Democrazie, Roma, Laterza & figli.

Diamond, Larry. 1999. Developing Democracy: Toward Consolidation, JHU Press.

Engler, Sara, Pytlas, Bartek and Deegan-Krause, Kevin. 2019. Assessing the Diversity of Anti-Establishment and Populist Politics in Central and Eastern Europe, in “West European Politics”, 42(6), pp. 1310-1336.

Falter, Jürgen W. and Schuhmann, Siegfries. 1993. Nichtwahl und Protestwahl: Zwei Seiten einer Medaille, in “Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte”, 11: pp. 36-49.

Giraudi, Giorgio. 2017. La Sfida Populista alla Democrazia Liberale, in Bianchi, Davide G. and Raniolo, Francesco. 2017. Limiti e Sfide della Rappresentanza Politica, Milano, FrancoAngeli.

Hawkins, Kirk A., Carlin, Ryan E., Littvay, Levente and Kaltwasser, Cristobal R., eds. 2018. The Ideational Approach to Populism: Concept, Theory, and Analysis, Routledge.

Heinisch, Reinhard. 2003. Success in Opposition–Failure in Government: Explaining the Performance of Right-Wing Populist Parties in Public Office, in “West European Politics”, 26(3), 91-130.

Ivaldi, Gilles. 2016. A New Course for the French Radical Right?. Radical Right-Wing Populist Parties in Western Europe, in “Into the Mainstream”, 225.

Jenne, Erin K. 2018. Is Nationalism or Ethnopopulism on the Rise Roday?, in “Ethnopolitics”, 17(5), 546-552.

Kazin, Michael. 1995. The Populist Persuasion: an American History, New Tuork, Casic Books.

Kellner, Douglas. 2016. American nightmare: Donald Trump, media spectacle, and authoritarian populism (Vol. 117). Springer.

Kelsen, Hans. 1981. On the Basis of Legal Validity, Am. J. Juris., 26, 178.

Kosař, David, Baroš, Jiří and Dufek, Pavel. 2019. The Twin Challenges to Separation of Powers in Central Europe: Technocratic Governance and Populism, in “European Constitutional Law Review”, 15(3), 427-461.

Krause, Werner and Wagner, Aiko. 2019. Becoming Part of the Gang? Established and Nonestablished Populist Parties and the Role of External Efficacy in “Party Politics”, 11.

Laclau, Ernesto. 2005. On Populist Reason, Verso.

Lefort, Claude. 1986 (trad.). The Political Forms of Modern Society: Bureaucracy, Democracy, Totalitarianism, MIT Press.

Levitsky, Steven and Ziblatt, Daniel. 2018. How democracies die, New York: Crown.

Mair, Peter. 2002. Populist Democracy vs Party Democracy, in Mény, Yves and Surel, Yves. 2002. Democracies and the populist challenge (pp. 81-98). Palgrave Macmillan, London.

Manin, Bernard. 2014. La Democrazia del Pubblico è In Pericolo?, in “Comunicazione politica”, 14(3), pp. 575-580.

Mastropaolo, Alfio. 2005. La Mucca Pazza della Democrazia. Nuove Destre, Populismo, Antipolitica, Torino, Bollati Boringhieri.

Mény Yves and Surel, Yves. 2000, Par le Peuple, pour le Peuple, Paris, Fayard; trad. it. Populismo e democrazia, Bologna, il Mulino, 2001.

Morlino, Leonardo. 2003. Democrazie e Democratizzazioni, Roma, Luiss.

Morlino, Leonardo and Raniolo, Francesco. 2018. Come la Crisi Economica Cambia la Democrazia: Tra Insoddisfazione e Protesta, Bologna, Il Mulino.

Mouffe, Chantal. 2000. The Democratic Paradox, Verso books.

Mounk, Yascha. 2018. The People vs. democracy: Why Our Freedom is in Danger and Hhow to Save It, Harvard University Press.

Mudde Cas and Rovira Kaltwasser Cristòbal, eds. 2012. Populism in Europe and the Americas, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Mudde, Cas. 2004. The Populist Zeitgeist, in “Government and opposition”, 39(4), pp. 541-563.

Müller, Jan-Werner. 2017. What Is Populism?, Penguin UK.

Pappas, Takis. 2019. Populists in Power, in “Journal of Democracy”, 30(2), pp. 70–84.

Pitkin, Hannah F. 1967. The Concept of Representation (Vol. 75), University of California Press.

Raniolo, Francesco. 2019. Democrazie sotto stress e tendenze illiberali, in «PARADOXA», XIII: 3, pp. 49-65.

Rosanvallon, Pierre. 2006. La Contro-Democrazia. La Democrazia Nell'era della Diffidenza, in “Ricerche di storia politica”, 9(3), pp. 289-302.

Rosanvallon, Pierre. 2017. Pensare il populismo, LIT EDIZIONI.

Sartori, Giovanni. 1967. La scienza politica, Il Politico, pp. 688-701.

Sartori, Giovanni. 2007. Democrazia: cosa è, Milano: Rizzoli.

Sartori, Giovanni. 1987.The Theory of Democracy Revisited, 2 voll., Chatham, N.J., Chatham House.

Schedler, Andreas. 1996. Anti-Political-Establishment Parties, in “Party politics”, 2(3), pp. 291-312.

Schumpeter, Joseph A. 1943. Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, Harper & Brothers.

Sorice, Michele. 2018. I Populismi e la Partecipazione Politica, in Anselmi, Manuel, Blokker, Paul and

Taylor, Steve L. 2016. The State of Democracy in Colombia: More Voting, Less Violence?, in “The Latin Americanist”, 60(2), pp. 169-190.

Tismaneanu, Vladimir. 2000. Hypotheses On Populism: the Politics of Charismatic Protest, in “East European Politics and Societies”, 15(1), pp. 10-17.

Tormey, Simon. 2018. Populism: Democracy's Pharmakon?, In “Policy Studies”, 39(3), pp. 260-273.

Tronconi, Filippo. 2018. The Italian Five Star Movement During the Crisis: Towards Normalisation?, in “South European Society and Politics”, 23(1), pp. 163-180.

Urbinati, Nadia. 2014. Democracy Disfigured, Harvard University Press.

Urbinati, Nadia. 2019. Me The People: How Populism Transforms Democracy, Harvard University Press.

Weyland, Kurt. 2013. Latin America's Authoritarian Drift: the Threat From the Populist Left, in “Journal of democracy”, 24(3), pp. 18-32.

Zakaria, Fareed. 1997. The Rise of Illiberal Democracy, in “Foreign Affairs”, 6, pp. 22-43.

Zanatta, Loris. 2004. Il populismo in America Latina. Il volto moderno di un immaginario antico, in “Filosofia politica”, 18(3), pp. 377-390.